On Wed, 12 Nov 2003 08:46:48 -0000, TX2
<tx2newscollection-invalid-@hotmail.com> wrote:
>In article <(E-Mail Removed)>,
>tx2newscollection-invalid-@hotmail.com, a.k.a TX2 says...
>
>> hmmm .... my posts were made to an 'exclusive' internal newsgroup
>
>Seems not the case having read some more.
>I better mind my P & Q's then!
Hi TX2.
As you have since discovered, it seems that UK-Bug are (probably
possibly - but open to links to show otherwise) one of the first
websites to merge the boundaries of usenet and web based forums -
where the source data is not publically and generically available to
anyone who wants it. Specially I'm talking about internal ISP usenet
posts. (thinking about it - doesnt dslreport mirror a few US based
ISPs???)
Now - be it a good thing, or bad, the fact is that a couple of ISPs
have said they have no objection to UK-Bug.net "mirroring" the
internal newsgroups. We've not pushed for publication rights -
despite this being technically viable - due to the fact we're at least
trying to be *partly* responsible here. Permitting posting rights at
this early stage is only asking for trouble. But it is available to a
*very* select few (whom we know and trust). Posting rights are
available for uk.telelcom.broadband though - not that its warranted
much with Google Groups etc.
Does anyone thing that ISP usenet groups are a "hiding" place for
those ISP subscribers only ? I'm interested to see on what level
subscribers *prefer* it that an ISPs groups are kept private from
other subscribers. Forget the "it could damage ISP reputation"
aspect, as I dont think thats a valid argument.
Since the setup of the WNP - I've had only Plusnet customers take
issue with the service. And both of them have changed their mind
about the service once Plusnet have commented on their acceptance of
the service.
Granted - this service could be pulled given bad user feeedback (with
an "unless you stop UK-Bug from mirroring my posts we're leaving your
ISP" petition) - but I honestly think that would be a shame.
Still ... I dont suppose anyone will mind greatly if your P&Qs are
offish for a while ;o)
--
Andy Jenkins
UK Broadband Usergroup :
http://www.uk-bug.net