PPPoE works, PPPoA doesn't.. ?

Hi, I'm a UK ADSL consumer and my Netgear router dropped my ADSL
connection one evening recently. It wouldn't re-connect until I re-ran
the Setup Wizard.
I was confused to see that it re-connected using PPPoE/
LLC instead of PPPoA/VC. My ISP is bemused and offers advice like
'switch off the router for 30 minutes' (to no avail).
It won't connect if I change it manually to PPPoA/VC. All other settings
seem fine.

Has anyone seen this before and what did you do?

JohnK


JohnK

JohnK wrote:
> Hi, I'm a UK ADSL consumer and my Netgear router dropped my ADSL
> connection one evening recently. It wouldn't re-connect until I re-ran
> the Setup Wizard.
> I was confused to see that it re-connected using PPPoE/
> LLC instead of PPPoA/VC. My ISP is bemused and offers advice like
> 'switch off the router for 30 minutes' (to no avail).
> It won't connect if I change it manually to PPPoA/VC. All other settings
> seem fine.
>
> Has anyone seen this before and what did you do?

What ISP are you using? What specific router?

Do you know if you are on BTwholesale equipment or another operators?
What speed/service do you have?

If it is working, is the question academic, or you are trying to "fix" it?

"JohnK" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message
news(E-Mail Removed)...
> Hi, I'm a UK ADSL consumer and my Netgear router dropped my ADSL
> connection one evening recently. It wouldn't re-connect until I
> re-ran
> the Setup Wizard.
> I was confused to see that it re-connected using PPPoE/
> LLC instead of PPPoA/VC. My ISP is bemused and offers advice like
> 'switch off the router for 30 minutes' (to no avail).
> It won't connect if I change it manually to PPPoA/VC. All other
> settings
> seem fine.
>
> Has anyone seen this before and what did you do?

When I was with Wanadoo, I connected with PPPoE/VC
If I remember that far back, I cud connect with PPPoA/VC, but it wud be
a low synch.

Try readin your ISP's help/forum.

On Sat, 21 Apr 2007 13:23:56 +0100, JohnK wrote:

> Hi, I'm a UK ADSL consumer and my Netgear router dropped my ADSL
> connection one evening recently. It wouldn't re-connect until I re-ran
> the Setup Wizard.
> I was confused to see that it re-connected using PPPoE/
> LLC instead of PPPoA/VC. My ISP is bemused and offers advice like
> 'switch off the router for 30 minutes' (to no avail).
> It won't connect if I change it manually to PPPoA/VC. All other settings
> seem fine.
>
> Has anyone seen this before and what did you do?
>
> JohnK

I have a Netgear ADSL router but it works perfectly well on PPPoA/VC. Just
a thought - have you got your country set for Europe or USA?
--
Remember that every good friend was once a stranger
http://www.valcopeland.co.uk/val/

On 21 Apr, 13:23, JohnK <johnk.dev.n...@gmail.com> wrote:

> Has anyone seen this before and what did you do?

Yes, go through all the settings manually, you may well find that VPI
and VCI are set incorrectly. Once these are set as appropriate
(normally 0 and 38) and all the rest (VX Mux, PPPoA) do a reboot of
the system and it should come up OK. Don't use the setup wizard, one
some Netgear models I've set up I have found it seems to detect things
incorrectly as you have found.

Regards

William MacLeod

JohnK wrote:
> Hi, I'm a UK ADSL consumer and my Netgear router dropped my ADSL
> connection one evening recently. It wouldn't re-connect until I re-ran
> the Setup Wizard.
> I was confused to see that it re-connected using PPPoE/
> LLC instead of PPPoA/VC. My ISP is bemused and offers advice like
> 'switch off the router for 30 minutes' (to no avail).
> It won't connect if I change it manually to PPPoA/VC. All other settings
> seem fine.
>
> Has anyone seen this before and what did you do?
>
> JohnK

I had this happen on an aol account a couple of years ago following a speed
upgrade..... very odd,....

Gaz

Some time ago BT changed their equipment and now both PPPoA and PPPoE should
work.
Anyone else found that PPPoE works better ?
Regards,
Martin

On 2007-04-22, Martin² <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:
> Some time ago BT changed their equipment and now both PPPoA and PPPoE should
> work.
> Anyone else found that PPPoE works better ?

Define better? PPPoE adds 14 or 16 bytes to every packet sent over
the ADSL circuit, and drops the MTU below Ethernet's 1500 bytes.
Something else would need to be quite a bit better to make up for
this.

Dennis Ferguson

On Sat, 21 Apr 2007 15:20:28 +0100, Paul Cupis wrote:

> What ISP are you using? What specific router?
>
> Do you know if you are on BTwholesale equipment or another operators?
> What speed/service do you have?
>
> If it is working, is the question academic, or you are trying to "fix"
> it?

Nildram, Netgear Rangemax DG834PN.

Well, since my download speed has deteriorated and my ISP insists I
should be connecting via PPPoA/VC, I'm kind of assuming the two issues
are related.
I'm on an up-to-8MB service and I get a connection speed of 5540kbps, an
IP profile of 1500kbps and a download speed of 1340kbps. I would like a
lot better. I have had consistent 380KBps download speeds in the past
and I have also seen times when I got 450KBps.

I have a BT engineer scheduled for Tuesday. So I'll see what he says.

JohnK

John Kelly wrote:
> I'm on an up-to-8MB service and I get a connection speed of 5540kbps, an
> IP profile of 1500kbps and a download speed of 1340kbps. I would like a
> lot better. I have had consistent 380KBps download speeds in the past
> and I have also seen times when I got 450KBps.

This suggests you are on a BTwholesale-based service. The lower IP
Profile suggests you have had a low sync event. Your speeds are fine
based on this profile.

If you maintain that sync speed for 3 days, the exchange should increase
your IP Profile to around 5000 and your speeds should similarly increase.

Reconfiguring the router to/from PPPoA/PPPoE may well cause the Profile
to remain lower.

Having said that, yes it should work as PPPoA, but PPPoE is still a
valid way of connecting, as BTwholesale support both.