(E-Mail Removed) wrote:
>> I'm in the same boat.
>> I made the mistake of complaining to my ISP when my speed suddenly dropped
>>
>> after four years of being at an average 2.5 Meg, down to about 1.5 Meg.
>> BT did excatly the same in my case - adjusted the equipment for stability
>> rather than speed.
>> I now get a "stable" - ie. slightly fewer drop-outs - connection at 1 Meg
>> or
>> below, with no chance of anything better in future.
>
> Which is just the point I made, ADSL needs to be rate adaptive, or
> allow the customer to adjust the SNR threshold, possibly with a
> minimum threshold, say 4db. If the customer sets it too low and
> he screws up his own connection, then it's his own fault.
> Seems to me that BT is setting an unreasonably conservative
> SNR of around 12db, when many modems will hold sync down
> to 2db.
> db is a logarithmic scale, if your modem holds sync at 2db, it
> should be quite happy with a 4db SNR ratio, and certainly doesn't
> need 12db.
> So you get the occasional burst ot transient noise, I'm quite
> happy if my sync speed drops to dialup speed, so long as it
> goes back up again as soon as the noise burst ends.
> If there is continuous noise on the line then it needs to be fixed.
Bt auto adjusts the noise margin according to disconnect rate. The
customer CAN in theory beat this by doing things at the router end.
I ended up with a 15dB moise margin at BT;'s end, but still connecting
way too fast for stability. Typically around 1-2dB SNR shown.
When I foud the magic turbo switch in the router and turned it off, I
got stability and a crap rate: I am now (at my behest) donwn to a 9db
rate, and have a resaonable compromise between speed and stability.
BT does what it does to optimize support calls. More people complain
more loudly if their connection is behaving like an Essex girls
knickers, than if it's just a tad slow.