Networking Forums

Networking Forums > Network Hardware > Home Networking > Remote Desktop over OpenVPN from standby fails

Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes

Remote Desktop over OpenVPN from standby fails

 
 
Daniel Kelly \(AKA Jack\)
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      06-11-2004, 11:25 AM
Hello,

I have a PC at work with a static IP address. For several months I've been
using OpenVPN to connect from home. I can easily run Remote Desktop
Connection over this OpenVPN connection.

Now that it's summer, I wanna reduce the amount of heat produced in my
office. So I want my PC to go into standby after half an hour of non use.
But this is where things go wrong. And this is very wierd. RDC seems to
crash for no apparent reason when I wake my sleeping office PC from home.
Has anyone else had this problem? Is there a fix? Here's the procedure
that causes the crash:

1) Before leaving work I log off and put my PC into standby.
2) At home, I send a magic packet to my office PC to wake it up.
3) After a few seconds, my OpenVPN client successfully connects to my office
PC. This proves the magic packet works.
4) I can now browse my office PC's shared folders and ping it. This proves
the OpenVPN connection works. It's possible that the OpenVPN connection is
a little more temperamental than usual but I'm not sure.
5) When I launch RDC, it crashes on the login page. My home computer won't
let me do anything (not even control-alt-delete). After a few minutes the
RDC client exits without any error message.
6) When I get back to work, I find my office PC has crashed and I have to do
a hard-reset.

And here's the list of things that definitely do work:

1) Do exactly the same as above but from a PC at work (not using OpenVPN).
The PC successfully comes out of standby and the RDC works fine. This
proves the magic packet wakes the PC and that RDC works fine after waking
the PC from standby.

2) Do exactly the same as the failing procedure but shutdown the PC fully
(ACPI state S5). I can boot my PC from home, initiate OpenVPN and run RDC
without fail. This proves the magic packet can be sent successfully from
home and that the OpenVPN is configured correctly.

So, my question is: why does RDC fail specifically when I wake my office PC
from standby from home? Perhaps the OpenVPN server doesn't like going into
standby? Or is there a bug in the RDC software?

My config is:

Office PC
- Windows XP Pro SP1 fully patched
- OpenVPN 1.6
- Intel D875PBZ motherboard with onboard gigabit Ethernet adapter
- I've set the BIOS to allow the Ethernet adapter to wake the PC
- The BIOS is set to put the PC into ACPI state S3 (suspend to RAM) when the
OS asks for "standby".
- I've told the Ethernet adapter's driver to forcefully wake the PC on
receiving a magic packet
- Running Kerio personal firewall. It's configured to allow the relevant
OpenVPN and RDC connections.
- My institute has a hardware firewall with 2 incoming ports open - one for
the magic packet and one for the OpenVPN connection.

Home PC
- Windows XP Pro SP1 fully patched
- OpenVPN 1.6
- 3Com 802.11g wireless network
- Pipex 512k ADSL connection
- Hardware router

Thanks,
Jack



 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
 
Daniel Kelly \(AKA Jack\)
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      06-14-2004, 09:03 AM
OK, I've looked into this some more and it's undeniable odd.

The problem seems to be that the Remote Desktop Connection server doesn't
like being woken from standby by Wake-On-LAN. I don't think the problem is
in anyway related to OpenVPN.

Here's what fails:

1) Put PC into standby
2) Go to another PC (either on the LAN or from home) and wake my Office PC
3) At this point, everything works - I can connect to my shared folders,
ping my office PC etc
4) But RDC fails! It crashed on the log-in

Here's what works:

Exactly the same as above but this time I wake the PC by pressing a button
on the keyboard.

Thanks,
Jack



"Daniel Kelly (AKA Jack)" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message
news:cac4nm$3058$(E-Mail Removed)...
> Hello,
>
> I have a PC at work with a static IP address. For several months I've

been
> using OpenVPN to connect from home. I can easily run Remote Desktop
> Connection over this OpenVPN connection.
>
> Now that it's summer, I wanna reduce the amount of heat produced in my
> office. So I want my PC to go into standby after half an hour of non use.
> But this is where things go wrong. And this is very wierd. RDC seems to
> crash for no apparent reason when I wake my sleeping office PC from home.
> Has anyone else had this problem? Is there a fix? Here's the procedure
> that causes the crash:
>
> 1) Before leaving work I log off and put my PC into standby.
> 2) At home, I send a magic packet to my office PC to wake it up.
> 3) After a few seconds, my OpenVPN client successfully connects to my

office
> PC. This proves the magic packet works.
> 4) I can now browse my office PC's shared folders and ping it. This

proves
> the OpenVPN connection works. It's possible that the OpenVPN connection

is
> a little more temperamental than usual but I'm not sure.
> 5) When I launch RDC, it crashes on the login page. My home computer

won't
> let me do anything (not even control-alt-delete). After a few minutes the
> RDC client exits without any error message.
> 6) When I get back to work, I find my office PC has crashed and I have to

do
> a hard-reset.
>
> And here's the list of things that definitely do work:
>
> 1) Do exactly the same as above but from a PC at work (not using OpenVPN).
> The PC successfully comes out of standby and the RDC works fine. This
> proves the magic packet wakes the PC and that RDC works fine after waking
> the PC from standby.
>
> 2) Do exactly the same as the failing procedure but shutdown the PC fully
> (ACPI state S5). I can boot my PC from home, initiate OpenVPN and run RDC
> without fail. This proves the magic packet can be sent successfully from
> home and that the OpenVPN is configured correctly.
>
> So, my question is: why does RDC fail specifically when I wake my office

PC
> from standby from home? Perhaps the OpenVPN server doesn't like going

into
> standby? Or is there a bug in the RDC software?
>
> My config is:
>
> Office PC
> - Windows XP Pro SP1 fully patched
> - OpenVPN 1.6
> - Intel D875PBZ motherboard with onboard gigabit Ethernet adapter
> - I've set the BIOS to allow the Ethernet adapter to wake the PC
> - The BIOS is set to put the PC into ACPI state S3 (suspend to RAM) when

the
> OS asks for "standby".
> - I've told the Ethernet adapter's driver to forcefully wake the PC on
> receiving a magic packet
> - Running Kerio personal firewall. It's configured to allow the relevant
> OpenVPN and RDC connections.
> - My institute has a hardware firewall with 2 incoming ports open - one

for
> the magic packet and one for the OpenVPN connection.
>
> Home PC
> - Windows XP Pro SP1 fully patched
> - OpenVPN 1.6
> - 3Com 802.11g wireless network
> - Pipex 512k ADSL connection
> - Hardware router
>
> Thanks,
> Jack
>
>
>



 
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Remote Desktop: The client could not connect to the remote compute crazyglue Windows Networking 6 02-24-2009 08:26 AM
Remote desktop, allow remote connections for some but deny remote for others steve Windows Networking 4 06-19-2007 01:35 PM
Installed openVPN, client fails when it asks for password GS Linux Networking 4 10-08-2006 09:40 PM
Reconnect fails after standby when using WPA Ryan Dahl Wireless Internet 0 05-05-2005 11:09 AM
MN-700 FAILS TO RECONNECT AFTER STANDBY john Broadband Hardware 4 07-06-2004 12:37 AM



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11