In article <dpdmvi$59h$1$(E-Mail Removed)>, "Ian Knight"
<(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:
>>>I think you'll find that the problem is that you don't have NetBeui
>>>installed on the XP machine -
>>>the machines are quite to talk to the Internet using TCP/IP and the XP
>>>machine has enough sense to 'wander' around a 98 machine to get files but
>>>the Win98 can't browse the Network Neighbourhood by itself without
>>>NetBeui.
>>>
>>>If you've only got the two machines, then I believe putting their IP
>>>addresses and machine name in the LMHOSTS file on each machine should sort
>>>of solve things. NetBeui is handy though if you have several machines
>>>connected on relatively small network with no Domain Controller and DHCP'd
>>>addresses - you can find the NetBeui driver for XP on the Internet or
>>>tucked
>>>away in a directory on your XP install CD.
>>>
>>>If you decide to do it that way - don't trust WinXP to install the files
>>>properly - the driver file usually has text file saying where each of the
>>>two files should be copied to on the XP machine and you need to do this
>>>from
>>>an 'explorer' window. If you don't then your network browsing will be
>>>unpredictable!
>>>
>>>I know this approach works (as opposed to using LMHosts) as I use it at
>>>home
>>>for linking my machine together,
>>>
>>> Ian
>>
>> All versions of Windows can use TCP/IP as the only network protocol.
>> Nothing in Windows networking requires, or has ever required NetBEUI.
>>
>> NetBEUI is an unsupported protocol in Windows XP. Yes, you can
>> install NetBEUI from the XP CD-ROM, but Microsoft hasn't tested it,
>> recommends not using it, and won't give technical support for it.
>>
>> Microsoft wouldn't have dropped support for NetBEUI if anything in
>> Windows networking needed NetBEUI.
>>
>> Using more than one network protocol is likely to cause problems,
>> especially when Windows XP is involved. I've written a web page with
>> details:
>>
>> Windows XP Network Protocols
>> http://www.practicallynetworked.com/..._protocols.htm
>
>Steve,
> Yes - you're right about Windows Networking but from bitter
>experience if the
>install isn't "spanking new" then installing NetBeui (on Win 98 machines
>certainly) can
>sometimes straighten things out by freshening/reinstating DLL's.
>
>I would take issue with your statement as being semantically incorrect
>
>"Nothing in Windows networking requires, or has ever required NetBEUI."
>
>If my memory serves - Windows for Workgroups 3.11 installed NetBeui and
>IPX/SPX by default
>(that's how I started with Peer to Peer without Novell!) and for a while was
>the 'native protocol' for
>Win NT when it first appeared. NetBeui must have served some purpose
>otherwise why did
>Microsoft go to all the trouble of enhancing the NetBios command set?
>
>Sorry to seem picky, but I have installed plenty of small (3-4 stations)
>peer to peer networks where the user is
>unwilling or incapable of getting their head around IP address, Subnet
>Masks, doesn't need internet access etc
>- NetBeui fits the bill and gives them something meaningful in Network
>Neighbourhood without getting too technical.
>
>Regards,
> Ian
Hi, Ian.
It's interesting to hear about your experience from way back when. I
used NetBEUI on my first network, because the web sites (e.g. J.
Helmig's "World of Windows Networking") and news groups that I read
recommended it.
But I changed my tune several years ago. I've installed and worked on
dozens of small peer-to-peer networks since then, and I now remove
NetBEUI from any network that I work on, leaving only TCP/IP.
If a network that has TCP/IP only works after adding NetBEUI,
something was (and still is) wrong with its setup, and NetBEUI is just
acting as a bandage and hiding the problem.
I think that you're right about WfW3.11. Since it installed both
IPX/SPX and NetBEUI, I stand by the semantic correctness of my
statement that "Nothing in Windows networking requires, or has ever
required NetBEUI." You could remove NetBEUI and use only IPX/SPX in
WfW3.11. NetBEUI was sufficient, but not necessary, for networking.
Microsoft then released TCP/IP-32 for WfW3.11, making both IPX/SPX
and NetBEUI unnecessary.
I think that it's fine to use NetBEUI on a network. However, if you
do, I strongly recommend removing all other protocols or, at least,
un-binding File and Printer Sharing from all other protocols, as I
describe on my protocols web page. In my experience, using more than
one protocol for File and Printer Sharing causes network browsing
problems, especially when Windows XP is involved.
What networking DLLs are straightened out by installing NetBEUI? I've
un-installed and re-installed Client for Microsoft Networks to do
that, but I'm not aware of any positive effect of adding a protocol.
--
Best Wishes,
Steve Winograd, MS-MVP (Windows Networking)
Please post any reply as a follow-up message in the news group
for everyone to see. I'm sorry, but I don't answer questions
addressed directly to me in E-mail or news groups.
Microsoft Most Valuable Professional - Windows Networking
http://mvp.support.microsoft.com
Steve Winograd's Networking FAQ
http://www.bcmaven.com/networking/faq.htm