| Home | Register | Members | Search | Links |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
Jim
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Gang,
It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the moment it only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists of the MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is wired directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I am forced to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations of the MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network that will be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to settle for WEP. I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this subject is the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the advantages of the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess maybe they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX dashboard, which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to support 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. I thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they would release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If they had stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being interested in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a firmware release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that extends the XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard to support the new option and that could be problematic because not everyone that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force MS offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously complicating matters. I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue better. Thanks reading my rant ;-) Jim New DGL-3420 info... Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/product...0/DGL-3420.jpg Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
|
|
| |
|
Chris H.
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA support on the MN-740. That
device came from the Xbox side of the hardware house at Microsoft, and not the now-defunct networking hardware team which created the regular computer routers/base stations and adapters which were dropped by Microsoft last spring. That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I understand it - would require a different hardware configuration or chip, not just the Xbox Dashboard setup as you suggest. So I seriously doubt any "update" for the MN-740 software will be forthcoming in the hardware area. -- Chris H. Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ Associate Expert Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... > Gang, > > It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the moment it > only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists of the > MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is wired > directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I am > forced > to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations of the > MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network that > will > be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to settle for > WEP. > > I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this subject is > the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the advantages of > the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess maybe > they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX dashboard, > which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. > > When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to support > 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. I > thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they would > release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped > manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If they > had > stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being > interested > in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. > > I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a firmware > release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that extends > the > XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard to > support the new option and that could be problematic because not everyone > that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force MS > offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously complicating > matters. > > I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my > livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost > exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue better. > > Thanks reading my rant ;-) > > Jim > > New DGL-3420 info... > Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/product...0/DGL-3420.jpg > Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 > > > > |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Chris H.
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Slight correction here. The MN-740 does run the Atheros chip, like the new
D-Link DGL-3420. However, I still would not look for a software update enabling WPA from the Microsoft folks. -- Chris H. Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ Associate Expert Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:OJkTlUA%(E-Mail Removed)... > Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA support on the MN-740. > That device came from the Xbox side of the hardware house at Microsoft, > and not the now-defunct networking hardware team which created the regular > computer routers/base stations and adapters which were dropped by > Microsoft last spring. > > That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I understand it - would require > a different hardware configuration or chip, not just the Xbox Dashboard > setup as you suggest. So I seriously doubt any "update" for the MN-740 > software will be forthcoming in the hardware area. > -- > Chris H. > Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC > Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ > Associate Expert > Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone > > > "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... >> Gang, >> >> It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the moment it >> only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists of the >> MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is >> wired >> directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I am >> forced >> to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations of the >> MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network that >> will >> be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to settle >> for >> WEP. >> >> I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this subject is >> the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the advantages >> of >> the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess maybe >> they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX dashboard, >> which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. >> >> When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to support >> 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. I >> thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they would >> release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped >> manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If they >> had >> stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being >> interested >> in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. >> >> I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a >> firmware >> release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that extends >> the >> XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard to >> support the new option and that could be problematic because not everyone >> that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force MS >> offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously complicating >> matters. >> >> I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my >> livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost >> exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue better. >> >> Thanks reading my rant ;-) >> >> Jim >> >> New DGL-3420 info... >> Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/product...0/DGL-3420.jpg >> Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 >> >> >> >> > > |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Joseph Wallis
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
And that is very sad. I mean why would you degrade all of the security in
your house for an Xbox? My current Xbox wireless setup is running the prorietary 256 dlink encryption with no degredation in performance. I don't see how WPA 256bit could be that worse. I'm soon switching to an MN-700, and it chaps my hide that MS doesn't include WPA support for the 740, otherwise I'd be buying another product from them. For now I'm going to find another vendor for the WPA bridge to the Xbox, and that is unacceptable. "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:OCYQAHB%(E-Mail Removed)... > Slight correction here. The MN-740 does run the Atheros chip, like the > new D-Link > DGL-3420. However, I still would not look for a software update enabling > WPA from the Microsoft folks. > -- > Chris H. > Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC > Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ > Associate Expert > Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone > > > "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > news:OJkTlUA%(E-Mail Removed)... >> Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA support on the MN-740. >> That device came from the Xbox side of the hardware house at Microsoft, >> and not the now-defunct networking hardware team which created the >> regular computer routers/base stations and adapters which were dropped by >> Microsoft last spring. >> >> That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I understand it - would require >> a different hardware configuration or chip, not just the Xbox Dashboard >> setup as you suggest. So I seriously doubt any "update" for the MN-740 >> software will be forthcoming in the hardware area. >> -- >> Chris H. >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> Associate Expert >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >> >> "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... >>> Gang, >>> >>> It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the moment >>> it >>> only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists of >>> the >>> MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is >>> wired >>> directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I am >>> forced >>> to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations of >>> the >>> MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network that >>> will >>> be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to settle >>> for >>> WEP. >>> >>> I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this subject >>> is >>> the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the advantages >>> of >>> the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess >>> maybe >>> they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX dashboard, >>> which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. >>> >>> When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to >>> support >>> 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. I >>> thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they would >>> release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped >>> manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If they >>> had >>> stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being >>> interested >>> in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. >>> >>> I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a >>> firmware >>> release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that extends >>> the >>> XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard to >>> support the new option and that could be problematic because not >>> everyone >>> that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force MS >>> offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously complicating >>> matters. >>> >>> I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my >>> livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost >>> exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue better. >>> >>> Thanks reading my rant ;-) >>> >>> Jim >>> >>> New DGL-3420 info... >>> Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/product...0/DGL-3420.jpg >>> Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 >>> >>> >>> >>> >> >> > > |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Chris H.
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
I agree, but there isn't anything as a user like you I can do except
complain via the Microsoft Wish program: http://register.microsoft.com/mswish/suggestion.asp However, since you've mentioned adding another router to your system you CAN segment the Xbox device off on its own portion of your LAN so it is isolated from the "important" stuff. Check out Microsoft MVP Barb Bowman's article regarding this subject on the Expert Zone: http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/u...an_segnet.mspx -- Chris H. Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ Associate Expert Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone "Joseph Wallis" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:O43XkhL%(E-Mail Removed)... > And that is very sad. I mean why would you degrade all of the security in > your house for an Xbox? My current Xbox wireless setup is running the > prorietary 256 dlink encryption with no degredation in performance. I > don't see how WPA 256bit could be that worse. > > I'm soon switching to an MN-700, and it chaps my hide that MS doesn't > include WPA support for the 740, otherwise I'd be buying another product > from them. For now I'm going to find another vendor for the WPA bridge to > the Xbox, and that is unacceptable. > > > > "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > news:OCYQAHB%(E-Mail Removed)... >> Slight correction here. The MN-740 does run the Atheros chip, like the >> new D-Link >> DGL-3420. However, I still would not look for a software update enabling >> WPA from the Microsoft folks. >> -- >> Chris H. >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> Associate Expert >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >> >> "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> news:OJkTlUA%(E-Mail Removed)... >>> Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA support on the MN-740. >>> That device came from the Xbox side of the hardware house at Microsoft, >>> and not the now-defunct networking hardware team which created the >>> regular computer routers/base stations and adapters which were dropped >>> by Microsoft last spring. >>> >>> That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I understand it - would >>> require a different hardware configuration or chip, not just the Xbox >>> Dashboard setup as you suggest. So I seriously doubt any "update" for >>> the MN-740 software will be forthcoming in the hardware area. >>> -- >>> Chris H. >>> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >>> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >>> Associate Expert >>> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >>> >>> >>> "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >>> news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... >>>> Gang, >>>> >>>> It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the moment >>>> it >>>> only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists of >>>> the >>>> MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is >>>> wired >>>> directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I am >>>> forced >>>> to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations of >>>> the >>>> MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network that >>>> will >>>> be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to settle >>>> for >>>> WEP. >>>> >>>> I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this subject >>>> is >>>> the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the advantages >>>> of >>>> the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess >>>> maybe >>>> they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX dashboard, >>>> which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. >>>> >>>> When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to >>>> support >>>> 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. I >>>> thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they would >>>> release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped >>>> manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If they >>>> had >>>> stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being >>>> interested >>>> in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. >>>> >>>> I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a >>>> firmware >>>> release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that extends >>>> the >>>> XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard to >>>> support the new option and that could be problematic because not >>>> everyone >>>> that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force MS >>>> offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously complicating >>>> matters. >>>> >>>> I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my >>>> livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost >>>> exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue better. >>>> >>>> Thanks reading my rant ;-) >>>> >>>> Jim >>>> >>>> New DGL-3420 info... >>>> Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/product...0/DGL-3420.jpg >>>> Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>> >>> >> >> > > |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Jim
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
I'm glad to see that others feel the same way. Thanks for the input... maybe
I'll enter something in the suggestion box. What are the odds that anyone looks at that and, if they do, that anyone will care. I know... very pessimistic, but I guess one never knows until you try ;-) This news group is always filled with the "it doesn't work" stories, and rightly so. But this one is more like "It works good, but would be great if only MS would extend their recent security focus to their wireless products". MS should know that this leaves the home network very vulnerable and is as important as blocking spyware and viruses, which they seem very focused on given XP SP2, their accusation of Giant for AntiSpyware, their upcoming beta for an AntiVirus, etc. I just would like to see a company step up to the plate and say, "hey - we know there is a significant (in this case security) gap in what this product provides and we'd like to fix it". Again, this topic is just cathartic in nature. It feels good to express the frustration and have others agree. Jim "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:uaOyWJM%(E-Mail Removed)... > I agree, but there isn't anything as a user like you I can do except > complain via the Microsoft Wish program: > http://register.microsoft.com/mswish/suggestion.asp > > However, since you've mentioned adding another router to your system you CAN > segment the Xbox device off on its own portion of your LAN so it is isolated > from the "important" stuff. > > Check out Microsoft MVP Barb Bowman's article regarding this subject on the > Expert Zone: > http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/u...an_segnet.mspx > -- > Chris H. > Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC > Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ > Associate Expert > Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone > > > "Joseph Wallis" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > news:O43XkhL%(E-Mail Removed)... > > And that is very sad. I mean why would you degrade all of the security in > > your house for an Xbox? My current Xbox wireless setup is running the > > prorietary 256 dlink encryption with no degredation in performance. I > > don't see how WPA 256bit could be that worse. > > > > I'm soon switching to an MN-700, and it chaps my hide that MS doesn't > > include WPA support for the 740, otherwise I'd be buying another product > > from them. For now I'm going to find another vendor for the WPA bridge to > > the Xbox, and that is unacceptable. > > > > > > > > "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > > news:OCYQAHB%(E-Mail Removed)... > >> Slight correction here. The MN-740 does run the Atheros chip, like the > >> new D-Link > >> DGL-3420. However, I still would not look for a software update enabling > >> WPA from the Microsoft folks. > >> -- > >> Chris H. > >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC > >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ > >> Associate Expert > >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone > >> > >> > >> "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > >> news:OJkTlUA%(E-Mail Removed)... > >>> Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA support on the MN-740. > >>> That device came from the Xbox side of the hardware house at Microsoft, > >>> and not the now-defunct networking hardware team which created the > >>> regular computer routers/base stations and adapters which were dropped > >>> by Microsoft last spring. > >>> > >>> That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I understand it - would > >>> require a different hardware configuration or chip, not just the Xbox > >>> Dashboard setup as you suggest. So I seriously doubt any "update" for > >>> the MN-740 software will be forthcoming in the hardware area. > >>> -- > >>> Chris H. > >>> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC > >>> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ > >>> Associate Expert > >>> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone > >>> > >>> > >>> "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > >>> news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... > >>>> Gang, > >>>> > >>>> It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the moment > >>>> it > >>>> only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists of > >>>> the > >>>> MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is > >>>> wired > >>>> directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I am > >>>> forced > >>>> to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations of > >>>> the > >>>> MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network that > >>>> will > >>>> be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to settle > >>>> for > >>>> WEP. > >>>> > >>>> I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this subject > >>>> is > >>>> the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the advantages > >>>> of > >>>> the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess > >>>> maybe > >>>> they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX dashboard, > >>>> which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. > >>>> > >>>> When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to > >>>> support > >>>> 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. I > >>>> thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they would > >>>> release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped > >>>> manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If they > >>>> had > >>>> stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being > >>>> interested > >>>> in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. > >>>> > >>>> I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a > >>>> firmware > >>>> release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that extends > >>>> the > >>>> XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard to > >>>> support the new option and that could be problematic because not > >>>> everyone > >>>> that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force MS > >>>> offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously complicating > >>>> matters. > >>>> > >>>> I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my > >>>> livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost > >>>> exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue better. > >>>> > >>>> Thanks reading my rant ;-) > >>>> > >>>> Jim > >>>> > >>>> New DGL-3420 info... > >>>> Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/product...0/DGL-3420.jpg > >>>> Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>> > >>> > >> > >> > > > > > > |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Chris H.
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Remember, this newsgroup is peer support. The MVPs you see posting here do
so voluntarily, on their own time. When the Broadband Networking products first came out, there were Microsoft hardware folks here nearly on a daily basis, but that division was dropped at Microsoft. The MN-740 comes of the Xbox side of the house, was never actively supported here officially, and I believe one needs to be a Master Chief to have access to those folks. 8-) -- Chris H. Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ Associate Expert Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:u0KRAuN%(E-Mail Removed)... > I'm glad to see that others feel the same way. Thanks for the input... > maybe > I'll enter something in the suggestion box. What are the odds that anyone > looks at that and, if they do, that anyone will care. I know... very > pessimistic, but I guess one never knows until you try ;-) > > This news group is always filled with the "it doesn't work" stories, and > rightly so. But this one is more like "It works good, but would be great > if > only MS would extend their recent security focus to their wireless > products". MS should know that this leaves the home network very > vulnerable > and is as important as blocking spyware and viruses, which they seem very > focused on given XP SP2, their accusation of Giant for AntiSpyware, their > upcoming beta for an AntiVirus, etc. > > I just would like to see a company step up to the plate and say, "hey - we > know there is a significant (in this case security) gap in what this > product > provides and we'd like to fix it". > > Again, this topic is just cathartic in nature. It feels good to express > the > frustration and have others agree. > > Jim > > "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message > news:uaOyWJM%(E-Mail Removed)... >> I agree, but there isn't anything as a user like you I can do except >> complain via the Microsoft Wish program: >> http://register.microsoft.com/mswish/suggestion.asp >> >> However, since you've mentioned adding another router to your system you > CAN >> segment the Xbox device off on its own portion of your LAN so it is > isolated >> from the "important" stuff. >> >> Check out Microsoft MVP Barb Bowman's article regarding this subject on > the >> Expert Zone: >> > http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/u...an_segnet.mspx >> -- >> Chris H. >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> Associate Expert >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >> >> "Joseph Wallis" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> news:O43XkhL%(E-Mail Removed)... >> > And that is very sad. I mean why would you degrade all of the security > in >> > your house for an Xbox? My current Xbox wireless setup is running the >> > prorietary 256 dlink encryption with no degredation in performance. I >> > don't see how WPA 256bit could be that worse. >> > >> > I'm soon switching to an MN-700, and it chaps my hide that MS doesn't >> > include WPA support for the 740, otherwise I'd be buying another >> > product >> > from them. For now I'm going to find another vendor for the WPA bridge > to >> > the Xbox, and that is unacceptable. >> > >> > >> > >> > "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> > news:OCYQAHB%(E-Mail Removed)... >> >> Slight correction here. The MN-740 does run the Atheros chip, like >> >> the >> >> new D-Link >> >> DGL-3420. However, I still would not look for a software update > enabling >> >> WPA from the Microsoft folks. >> >> -- >> >> Chris H. >> >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> >> Associate Expert >> >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >> >> >> >> >> "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> >> news:OJkTlUA%(E-Mail Removed)... >> >>> Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA support on the >> >>> MN-740. >> >>> That device came from the Xbox side of the hardware house at > Microsoft, >> >>> and not the now-defunct networking hardware team which created the >> >>> regular computer routers/base stations and adapters which were >> >>> dropped >> >>> by Microsoft last spring. >> >>> >> >>> That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I understand it - would >> >>> require a different hardware configuration or chip, not just the Xbox >> >>> Dashboard setup as you suggest. So I seriously doubt any "update" >> >>> for >> >>> the MN-740 software will be forthcoming in the hardware area. >> >>> -- >> >>> Chris H. >> >>> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> >>> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> >>> Associate Expert >> >>> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >>> >> >>> >> >>> "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> >>> news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... >> >>>> Gang, >> >>>> >> >>>> It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the > moment >> >>>> it >> >>>> only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists >> >>>> of >> >>>> the >> >>>> MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is >> >>>> wired >> >>>> directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I >> >>>> am >> >>>> forced >> >>>> to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations >> >>>> of >> >>>> the >> >>>> MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network > that >> >>>> will >> >>>> be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to > settle >> >>>> for >> >>>> WEP. >> >>>> >> >>>> I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this > subject >> >>>> is >> >>>> the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the > advantages >> >>>> of >> >>>> the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess >> >>>> maybe >> >>>> they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX > dashboard, >> >>>> which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. >> >>>> >> >>>> When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to >> >>>> support >> >>>> 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. >> >>>> I >> >>>> thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they >> >>>> would >> >>>> release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped >> >>>> manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If > they >> >>>> had >> >>>> stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being >> >>>> interested >> >>>> in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. >> >>>> >> >>>> I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a >> >>>> firmware >> >>>> release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that > extends >> >>>> the >> >>>> XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard >> >>>> to >> >>>> support the new option and that could be problematic because not >> >>>> everyone >> >>>> that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force > MS >> >>>> offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously > complicating >> >>>> matters. >> >>>> >> >>>> I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my >> >>>> livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost >> >>>> exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue >> >>>> better. >> >>>> >> >>>> Thanks reading my rant ;-) >> >>>> >> >>>> Jim >> >>>> >> >>>> New DGL-3420 info... >> >>>> Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/product...0/DGL-3420.jpg >> >>>> Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 >> >>>> >> >>>> >> >>>> >> >>>> >> >>> >> >>> >> >> >> >> >> > >> > >> >> > > |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Tim
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Well, for me it is justthe fact i flatout feel denied. I
love the product as it works well. And what chaps my hide about it is this little quote that can be found on the product information page for the mn-740: "Upgradeable for future security features." found here under High Security: http://www.microsoft.com/hardware/br...etworking/prod uctdetails.aspx?pid=015# to me, that says they had plans to do it, and for the better part left us high and dry....and more importantly, unsecure.... Tim >-----Original Message----- >I'm glad to see that others feel the same way. Thanks for the input... maybe >I'll enter something in the suggestion box. What are the odds that anyone >looks at that and, if they do, that anyone will care. I know... very >pessimistic, but I guess one never knows until you try ;- ) > >This news group is always filled with the "it doesn't work" stories, and >rightly so. But this one is more like "It works good, but would be great if >only MS would extend their recent security focus to their wireless >products". MS should know that this leaves the home network very vulnerable >and is as important as blocking spyware and viruses, which they seem very >focused on given XP SP2, their accusation of Giant for AntiSpyware, their >upcoming beta for an AntiVirus, etc. > >I just would like to see a company step up to the plate and say, "hey - we >know there is a significant (in this case security) gap in what this product >provides and we'd like to fix it". > >Again, this topic is just cathartic in nature. It feels good to express the >frustration and have others agree. > >Jim > >"Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >news:uaOyWJM%(E-Mail Removed)... >> I agree, but there isn't anything as a user like you I can do except >> complain via the Microsoft Wish program: >> http://register.microsoft.com/mswish/suggestion.asp >> >> However, since you've mentioned adding another router to your system you >CAN >> segment the Xbox device off on its own portion of your LAN so it is >isolated >> from the "important" stuff. >> >> Check out Microsoft MVP Barb Bowman's article regarding this subject on >the >> Expert Zone: >> >http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/u...tworking/exper t/bowman_segnet.mspx >> -- >> Chris H. >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> Associate Expert >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >> >> "Joseph Wallis" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> news:O43XkhL%(E-Mail Removed)... >> > And that is very sad. I mean why would you degrade all of the security >in >> > your house for an Xbox? My current Xbox wireless setup is running the >> > prorietary 256 dlink encryption with no degredation in performance. I >> > don't see how WPA 256bit could be that worse. >> > >> > I'm soon switching to an MN-700, and it chaps my hide that MS doesn't >> > include WPA support for the 740, otherwise I'd be buying another product >> > from them. For now I'm going to find another vendor for the WPA bridge >to >> > the Xbox, and that is unacceptable. >> > >> > >> > >> > "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> > news:OCYQAHB%(E-Mail Removed)... >> >> Slight correction here. The MN-740 does run the Atheros chip, like the >> >> new D-Link >> >> DGL-3420. However, I still would not look for a software update >enabling >> >> WPA from the Microsoft folks. >> >> -- >> >> Chris H. >> >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> >> Associate Expert >> >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >> >> >> >> >> "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> >> news:OJkTlUA%(E-Mail Removed)... >> >>> Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA support on the MN-740. >> >>> That device came from the Xbox side of the hardware house at >Microsoft, >> >>> and not the now-defunct networking hardware team which created the >> >>> regular computer routers/base stations and adapters which were dropped >> >>> by Microsoft last spring. >> >>> >> >>> That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I understand it - would >> >>> require a different hardware configuration or chip, not just the Xbox >> >>> Dashboard setup as you suggest. So I seriously doubt any "update" for >> >>> the MN-740 software will be forthcoming in the hardware area. >> >>> -- >> >>> Chris H. >> >>> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >> >>> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >> >>> Associate Expert >> >>> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >> >>> >> >>> >> >>> "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >> >>> news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... >> >>>> Gang, >> >>>> >> >>>> It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support WPA-PSK (at the >moment >> >>>> it >> >>>> only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My network consists of >> >>>> the >> >>>> MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home computer (XP Pro SP2) is >> >>>> wired >> >>>> directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for my work laptop. I am >> >>>> forced >> >>>> to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because of the limitations of >> >>>> the >> >>>> MN740. I am in the process of putting a new computer on my network >that >> >>>> will >> >>>> be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but again, I'll have to >settle >> >>>> for >> >>>> WEP. >> >>>> >> >>>> I think the issue that has me a little animated regarding this >subject >> >>>> is >> >>>> the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It has all the >advantages >> >>>> of >> >>>> the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like the MN740 (I guess >> >>>> maybe >> >>>> they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks into the XBOX >dashboard, >> >>>> which is the only advantage the MN740 had over the competitors. >> >>>> >> >>>> When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one on the market to >> >>>> support >> >>>> 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the standard did exist. I >> >>>> thought for sure (and everyone else did on this newsgroup) they would >> >>>> release a firmware update to support WPA. I know that MS has stopped >> >>>> manufacturing their line of wireless products EXCEPT the MN740. If >they >> >>>> had >> >>>> stopped making and selling this I could understand them not being >> >>>> interested >> >>>> in adding this feature, but they are still selling it. >> >>>> >> >>>> I'm not sure if there are technical limitations in distributing a >> >>>> firmware >> >>>> release to support the WPA standard to a piece of hardware that >extends >> >>>> the >> >>>> XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to patch the dashboard to >> >>>> support the new option and that could be problematic because not >> >>>> everyone >> >>>> that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX Live. This would force >MS >> >>>> offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - obviously >complicating >> >>>> matters. >> >>>> >> >>>> I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - in fact I owe my >> >>>> livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use their tools almost >> >>>> exclusively, but I really would like to understand this issue better. >> >>>> >> >>>> Thanks reading my rant ;-) >> >>>> >> >>>> Jim >> >>>> >> >>>> New DGL-3420 info... >> >>>> Picture: ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/products/DGL-3420/DGL- 3420.jpg >> >>>> Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 >> >>>> >> >>>> >> >>>> >> >>>> >> >>> >> >>> >> >> >> >> >> > >> > >> >> > > >. > |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Chris H.
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
I agree, Tim. We all want the best security on our LANs, and it is more
necessary is some residential areas than others. However, there is a way to get around it as I posted previously, to segment your LAN to isolate the Xbox, and provide higher security for your computers. What can anyone do accessing your Xbox? 8-) -- Chris H. Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ Associate Expert Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone "Tim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:07b001c4f9d9$2656d1e0$(E-Mail Removed)... > Well, for me it is justthe fact i flatout feel denied. I > love the product as it works well. And what chaps my > hide about it is this little quote that can be found on > the product information page for the mn-740: > > "Upgradeable for future security features." > found here under High Security: > http://www.microsoft.com/hardware/br...etworking/prod > uctdetails.aspx?pid=015# > > to me, that says they had plans to do it, and for the > better part left us high and dry....and more importantly, > unsecure.... > > > Tim >>-----Original Message----- >>I'm glad to see that others feel the same way. Thanks > for the input... maybe >>I'll enter something in the suggestion box. What are the > odds that anyone >>looks at that and, if they do, that anyone will care. I > know... very >>pessimistic, but I guess one never knows until you try ;- > ) >> >>This news group is always filled with the "it doesn't > work" stories, and >>rightly so. But this one is more like "It works good, > but would be great if >>only MS would extend their recent security focus to > their wireless >>products". MS should know that this leaves the home > network very vulnerable >>and is as important as blocking spyware and viruses, > which they seem very >>focused on given XP SP2, their accusation of Giant for > AntiSpyware, their >>upcoming beta for an AntiVirus, etc. >> >>I just would like to see a company step up to the plate > and say, "hey - we >>know there is a significant (in this case security) gap > in what this product >>provides and we'd like to fix it". >> >>Again, this topic is just cathartic in nature. It feels > good to express the >>frustration and have others agree. >> >>Jim >> >>"Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >>news:uaOyWJM%(E-Mail Removed).. . >>> I agree, but there isn't anything as a user like you I > can do except >>> complain via the Microsoft Wish program: >>> http://register.microsoft.com/mswish/suggestion.asp >>> >>> However, since you've mentioned adding another router > to your system you >>CAN >>> segment the Xbox device off on its own portion of your > LAN so it is >>isolated >>> from the "important" stuff. >>> >>> Check out Microsoft MVP Barb Bowman's article > regarding this subject on >>the >>> Expert Zone: >>> >>http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/u...tworking/exper > t/bowman_segnet.mspx >>> -- >>> Chris H. >>> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >>> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >>> Associate Expert >>> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >>> >>> >>> "Joseph Wallis" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >>> news:O43XkhL%(E-Mail Removed)... >>> > And that is very sad. I mean why would you degrade > all of the security >>in >>> > your house for an Xbox? My current Xbox wireless > setup is running the >>> > prorietary 256 dlink encryption with no degredation > in performance. I >>> > don't see how WPA 256bit could be that worse. >>> > >>> > I'm soon switching to an MN-700, and it chaps my > hide that MS doesn't >>> > include WPA support for the 740, otherwise I'd be > buying another product >>> > from them. For now I'm going to find another vendor > for the WPA bridge >>to >>> > the Xbox, and that is unacceptable. >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >>> > news:OCYQAHB%(E-Mail Removed)... >>> >> Slight correction here. The MN-740 does run the > Atheros chip, like the >>> >> new D-Link >>> >> DGL-3420. However, I still would not look for a > software update >>enabling >>> >> WPA from the Microsoft folks. >>> >> -- >>> >> Chris H. >>> >> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >>> >> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >>> >> Associate Expert >>> >> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >>> >> >>> >> >>> >> "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >>> >> news:OJkTlUA%(E-Mail Removed)... >>> >>> Jim, I agree in your venting on the lack of WPA > support on the MN-740. >>> >>> That device came from the Xbox side of the > hardware house at >>Microsoft, >>> >>> and not the now-defunct networking hardware team > which created the >>> >>> regular computer routers/base stations and > adapters which were dropped >>> >>> by Microsoft last spring. >>> >>> >>> >>> That said, putting WPA on the MN-740 - as I > understand it - would >>> >>> require a different hardware configuration or > chip, not just the Xbox >>> >>> Dashboard setup as you suggest. So I seriously > doubt any "update" for >>> >>> the MN-740 software will be forthcoming in the > hardware area. >>> >>> -- >>> >>> Chris H. >>> >>> Microsoft Windows MVP/Tablet PC >>> >>> Tablet Creations - http://nicecreations.us/ >>> >>> Associate Expert >>> >>> Expert Zone - > www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> "Jim" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message >>> >>> news:eoY6gS$(E-Mail Removed)... >>> >>>> Gang, >>> >>>> >>> >>>> It seems a shame that the MN740 doesn't support > WPA-PSK (at the >>moment >>> >>>> it >>> >>>> only supports the weaker 64/128 WEP standard). My > network consists of >>> >>>> the >>> >>>> MN820 wireless G kit and the MN740. My home > computer (XP Pro SP2) is >>> >>>> wired >>> >>>> directly to the MN700 and I use the PCM card for > my work laptop. I am >>> >>>> forced >>> >>>> to use the flimsy WEP for my encryption because > of the limitations of >>> >>>> the >>> >>>> MN740. I am in the process of putting a new > computer on my network >>that >>> >>>> will >>> >>>> be connected via a PCI Wireless G card, but > again, I'll have to >>settle >>> >>>> for >>> >>>> WEP. >>> >>>> >>> >>>> I think the issue that has me a little animated > regarding this >>subject >>> >>>> is >>> >>>> the new DLink game adapter (see links below). It > has all the >>advantages >>> >>>> of >>> >>>> the MN740 + WPA-PSK... and it looks exactly like > the MN740 (I guess >>> >>>> maybe >>> >>>> they make it for Microsoft). It even has hooks > into the XBOX >>dashboard, >>> >>>> which is the only advantage the MN740 had over > the competitors. >>> >>>> >>> >>>> When MS released the MN740 it was the newest one > on the market to >>> >>>> support >>> >>>> 802.11G, but didn't support WPA even though the > standard did exist. I >>> >>>> thought for sure (and everyone else did on this > newsgroup) they would >>> >>>> release a firmware update to support WPA. I know > that MS has stopped >>> >>>> manufacturing their line of wireless products > EXCEPT the MN740. If >>they >>> >>>> had >>> >>>> stopped making and selling this I could > understand them not being >>> >>>> interested >>> >>>> in adding this feature, but they are still > selling it. >>> >>>> >>> >>>> I'm not sure if there are technical limitations > in distributing a >>> >>>> firmware >>> >>>> release to support the WPA standard to a piece of > hardware that >>extends >>> >>>> the >>> >>>> XBOX functionality. I guess they would have to > patch the dashboard to >>> >>>> support the new option and that could be > problematic because not >>> >>>> everyone >>> >>>> that has the MN740 uses it to connect to XBOX > Live. This would force >>MS >>> >>>> offer some sort of CD to update the dashboard - > obviously >>complicating >>> >>>> matters. >>> >>>> >>> >>>> I guess I needed to vent ;-) I'm not a MS basher - > in fact I owe my >>> >>>> livelihood to MS as I am a programmer and use > their tools almost >>> >>>> exclusively, but I really would like to > understand this issue better. >>> >>>> >>> >>>> Thanks reading my rant ;-) >>> >>>> >>> >>>> Jim >>> >>>> >>> >>>> New DGL-3420 info... >>> >>>> Picture: > ftp://ftp10.dlink.com/images/products/DGL-3420/DGL- > 3420.jpg >>> >>>> Specs: http://games.dlink.com/products/?pid=383 >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >> >>> >> >>> > >>> > >>> >>> >> >> >>. >> |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
Barb Bowman [MVP-Windows]
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Since I first wrote about segmenting WEP segments, things have changed
in the security world. It's no longer safe to have a WEP only segment on the same network under most conditions. A new column on wireless zecurity reflecting today's frames of references will be up very soon on the Expert Zone. I've replaced my MN-740s with DLink DWL-G820's which offer WPA. I've removed all WEP only devices from my network. On Thu, 13 Jan 2005 18:26:32 -0800, "Chris H." <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote: >However, there is a way to >get around it as I posted previously, to segment your LAN to isolate the >Xbox, and provide higher security for your computers. -- Barb Bowman Expert Zone Columnist http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone MS-MVP (Windows) |
|
|
|
|
|||
|
|||
|
|
|
| |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Chris H | terrimoor@gmail.com | Broadband Hardware | 0 | 03-29-2006 07:47 AM |
| Attn Chris H, Got my MN-740 Working | Danny | Broadband Hardware | 1 | 02-26-2005 03:22 PM |
| Lookoing for Chris Hassler | paramacs | Broadband Hardware | 1 | 08-16-2004 10:24 PM |
| Chris H -- MN-100 current firmware? | Barry Gordon | Broadband Hardware | 2 | 07-11-2004 05:00 PM |
| CB Chris- AUP | Nomen Nescio | Broadband | 1 | 07-23-2003 04:42 AM |
Forum Software Powered by vBulletin®, Copyright Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2 ©2009, Crawlability, Inc. |



Linear Mode

