Networking Forums

Networking Forums > Network Hardware > Broadband Hardware > MN-740 wish list

Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes

MN-740 wish list

 
 
Sean
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      01-18-2004, 01:38 PM
for all of you that are having a hell of a time with the mn-740, i recommend
you check out the following link and tell M$ that they need to get their act
together.

http://support.microsoft.com/default...b;en-us;114491

first on my list of suggestions is to get a web interface to configure the
thing. i believe that half of your firmware update problems could be easily
resolved if you could update the firmware from a web interface. not to
mention that the majority of the problems i'm reading begin with getting the
device configured, and it's a pain to sit in front of an xbox to configure
it, especially WEP keys. ironically, i had no problems configuring the
device. from the get go. i enabled broadcast of ssid and disabled all
security settings on my router, as i figured like with all Micro$oft
products that there would be all kinds of problem if there was a hint of
concious security in a home network. Secondly, I would request support for
WPA. I see no reason why the MN-740 (actually I do, but that's another
rant), doesn't already have this in it, and it's a reflection once again of
Micro$oft's lack of concern for your privacy and security. The following is
the actual email I sent to M$, for which I did get a polite response saying
they value my suggesstions, yeah right :

************************************************** *****

1) In accordance with wi-fi certification WPA support should be added to
this device. I have to compromise the security of my entire wireless
network because of the lack of support for this within this adapter. At the
same time support for 4 wep keys should be added, as this is a basic feature
and requirement of all wep enabled devices. It appears no consideration was
given to security when releasing this product.

2) Ability to configure from any web browser. Configuring from the xbox
console is extremely limiting. In Canada this is a $200 device and this
seriously limits the ability to administer and limits this as being an xbox
exclusive product. The bottom line is that this is a wireless bridge, and
therefore it should be able to be administered it as such.

3) There is no way to configure the device without DHCP. You would think
again that this would be the most basic of features with any network
adapter. In fact, this is the only ethernet adapter that I know of that
absolutely requires DHCP. For security reason I prefer to not use DHCP on
my network. Once again I am forced to accomodate this by implenting DHCP.

Hopefully, the above suggestions will make it into a future firmware release
for this product as this product would be a much better product for it. I
would consider the above to be basic requirements for any product of this
type, and at $200 I would hope that Microsoft will implement these
recommendations as soon as possible.


 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
 
faustus
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      01-18-2004, 06:53 PM
Sean,
Outstanding letter and I couldn't agree with you more. I
have 2 of these devices asnd I haven't had a problem
configuring them at all to be honest. I agree, the
features you suggested need to be implemented ASAP.
Especially with a $150.00 price tag.
I still have not heard anything from M$ Tech Support
helping me with updating the firmware for the MN-740's. I
spent 2 1/2 hours on the phone with them without any
luck. The only response I got was to try updating with
another PC. I have tried 4 different ones with different
OS' and no luck. I am starting to wish I would have went
with the Linksys Wireless G Game adapters. I like my M$
products but this is just ridiculous. Thanks for the Link!

faustus
>-----Original Message-----
>for all of you that are having a hell of a time with the

mn-740, i recommend
>you check out the following link and tell M$ that they

need to get their act
>together.
>
>http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;en-

us;114491
>
>first on my list of suggestions is to get a web

interface to configure the
>thing. i believe that half of your firmware update

problems could be easily
>resolved if you could update the firmware from a web

interface. not to
>mention that the majority of the problems i'm reading

begin with getting the
>device configured, and it's a pain to sit in front of an

xbox to configure
>it, especially WEP keys. ironically, i had no problems

configuring the
>device. from the get go. i enabled broadcast of ssid

and disabled all
>security settings on my router, as i figured like with

all Micro$oft
>products that there would be all kinds of problem if

there was a hint of
>concious security in a home network. Secondly, I would

request support for
>WPA. I see no reason why the MN-740 (actually I do, but

that's another
>rant), doesn't already have this in it, and it's a

reflection once again of
>Micro$oft's lack of concern for your privacy and

security. The following is
>the actual email I sent to M$, for which I did get a

polite response saying
>they value my suggesstions, yeah right :
>
>************************************************* ******
>
>1) In accordance with wi-fi certification WPA support

should be added to
>this device. I have to compromise the security of my

entire wireless
>network because of the lack of support for this within

this adapter. At the
>same time support for 4 wep keys should be added, as

this is a basic feature
>and requirement of all wep enabled devices. It appears

no consideration was
>given to security when releasing this product.
>
>2) Ability to configure from any web browser.

Configuring from the xbox
>console is extremely limiting. In Canada this is a $200

device and this
>seriously limits the ability to administer and limits

this as being an xbox
>exclusive product. The bottom line is that this is a

wireless bridge, and
>therefore it should be able to be administered it as

such.
>
>3) There is no way to configure the device without

DHCP. You would think
>again that this would be the most basic of features with

any network
>adapter. In fact, this is the only ethernet adapter

that I know of that
>absolutely requires DHCP. For security reason I prefer

to not use DHCP on
>my network. Once again I am forced to accomodate this

by implenting DHCP.
>
>Hopefully, the above suggestions will make it into a

future firmware release
>for this product as this product would be a much better

product for it. I
>would consider the above to be basic requirements for

any product of this
>type, and at $200 I would hope that Microsoft will

implement these
>recommendations as soon as possible.
>
>
>.
>

 
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
RSSI list Cirrosi Wireless Internet 0 10-24-2007 04:17 PM
Help: FTP File List Amy Lee Linux Networking 7 07-22-2007 10:11 PM
My ISP wish list Simon Ough Broadband 17 11-16-2005 09:19 AM
DNS Search list David Heise Windows Networking 3 08-16-2005 09:59 PM
Dialup List? Si. Broadband 1 07-10-2004 10:32 AM



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11