Networking Forums

Networking Forums > Wireless Networking > Wireless Internet > Linksys WUSB54G - Bad experience, seeking alternates / advice!

Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes

Linksys WUSB54G - Bad experience, seeking alternates / advice!

 
 
Marc Brown
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      11-30-2003, 02:46 AM
Subject says it all, really. I picked up one of these at Best Buy,
installed it, and gave myself (and my brother) a four-hour headache trying
to get WPA working with it (which was finally accomplished), only to note
that the typical throughput is about 100-120 KBytes/second. Signal
strength fluctuates between three and five bars, and it also seems to
think I'm getting 24-54 Mb/s. I sure the heck am not. Stupid me for
mapping a drive wirelessly; half the time, files sent to the wireless PC
are completely lost because the bandwidth just wasn't good enough. This
is totally unacceptable.

Possibilities: WPA? It works, no doubt about that. I had to install a
driver obtained from Microsoft's homepage. The router is definitely using
WPA and the configuration menus for the Linksys WUSB54G definitely seem to
be telling me that it's using WPA. Could this protection be causing the
dramatically slow transfer rates? (If so, it's time to dump this adapter.)

USB? It's not 2.0. So no 54Mb/s for me. But this does present some
confusion. 11Mb/s is still whatever.. ~1300 Kbytes/second, right? I just
don't see how the 100K/s I'm getting can be confused with 1300K/s.
They're not even close. Plus, what does this mean about the rates the
Linksys status menu tells me I'm getting? 24-54 Mb/s. That range
shouldn't even be possible, I'd thought.

Okay, enough of that. I've used a Linksys product now and I have a very
bad taste in my mouth. The snippets I've read from the closest thing I
could find to reviews have been suggesting that Linksys is crap and
D-Link is gold. Is this accurate? I'm going to probably be trading my
current device in for something else. At this stage, I'm thinking D-Link
is the way to go. Perhaps I'm wrong. I do reckon I'll go ahead and
remove the soundcard so I can put a wireless card in its place. That way,
even if I get bit by the Linksys bottleneck again, I can still look
forward to (by the current math) about 500KB/s, which is adequate for my
needs.

Any help appreciated!
 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
 
Joe Hayes
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      11-30-2003, 04:03 AM
I use a WRT54G router from Linksys and a notebook with built-in Broadcom 54g
adapter and WPA has no noticeable impact on performance.

"Marc Brown" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message
news:(E-Mail Removed) om...
> Subject says it all, really. I picked up one of these at Best Buy,
> installed it, and gave myself (and my brother) a four-hour headache trying
> to get WPA working with it (which was finally accomplished), only to note
> that the typical throughput is about 100-120 KBytes/second. Signal
> strength fluctuates between three and five bars, and it also seems to
> think I'm getting 24-54 Mb/s. I sure the heck am not. Stupid me for
> mapping a drive wirelessly; half the time, files sent to the wireless PC
> are completely lost because the bandwidth just wasn't good enough. This
> is totally unacceptable.
>
> Possibilities: WPA? It works, no doubt about that. I had to install a
> driver obtained from Microsoft's homepage. The router is definitely using
> WPA and the configuration menus for the Linksys WUSB54G definitely seem to
> be telling me that it's using WPA. Could this protection be causing the
> dramatically slow transfer rates? (If so, it's time to dump this

adapter.)
>
> USB? It's not 2.0. So no 54Mb/s for me. But this does present some
> confusion. 11Mb/s is still whatever.. ~1300 Kbytes/second, right? I just
> don't see how the 100K/s I'm getting can be confused with 1300K/s.
> They're not even close. Plus, what does this mean about the rates the
> Linksys status menu tells me I'm getting? 24-54 Mb/s. That range
> shouldn't even be possible, I'd thought.
>
> Okay, enough of that. I've used a Linksys product now and I have a very
> bad taste in my mouth. The snippets I've read from the closest thing I
> could find to reviews have been suggesting that Linksys is crap and
> D-Link is gold. Is this accurate? I'm going to probably be trading my
> current device in for something else. At this stage, I'm thinking D-Link


> is the way to go. Perhaps I'm wrong. I do reckon I'll go ahead and
> remove the soundcard so I can put a wireless card in its place. That way,
> even if I get bit by the Linksys bottleneck again, I can still look
> forward to (by the current math) about 500KB/s, which is adequate for my
> needs.
>
> Any help appreciated!



 
Reply With Quote
 
DavidJ01
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      11-30-2003, 04:10 AM
Mark,

Are you absolutely sure that this adapter supports WPA ? I have the same
one and the documentation does not indicate it supports WPA, only WEP.
This has also been confirmed verbally by Linksys tech support. Right now
I'm waiting on written confirmation. Also, I was unable to enter a WPA key.
The WZC utility, as well as the WLAN utility from Linksys did not allow a
WPA key, only a 64 or 128 bit WEP key.

Also, I think that the device itself (either the hardware or firmware) has
to support WPA in order for the driver to have any affect. If the hardware
doesn't support WPA, then I suspect you're not gaining anything from the
driver you downloaded.

And finally, as I think about this some more, what driver did you download ?
I know there's a MS patch that's needed for WPA to work with XP, but its for
hardware that's WPA compliant.

David...


"Marc Brown" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message
news:(E-Mail Removed) om...
> Subject says it all, really. I picked up one of these at Best Buy,
> installed it, and gave myself (and my brother) a four-hour headache trying
> to get WPA working with it (which was finally accomplished), only to note
> that the typical throughput is about 100-120 KBytes/second. Signal
> strength fluctuates between three and five bars, and it also seems to
> think I'm getting 24-54 Mb/s. I sure the heck am not. Stupid me for
> mapping a drive wirelessly; half the time, files sent to the wireless PC
> are completely lost because the bandwidth just wasn't good enough. This
> is totally unacceptable.
>
> Possibilities: WPA? It works, no doubt about that. I had to install a
> driver obtained from Microsoft's homepage. The router is definitely using
> WPA and the configuration menus for the Linksys WUSB54G definitely seem to
> be telling me that it's using WPA. Could this protection be causing the
> dramatically slow transfer rates? (If so, it's time to dump this

adapter.)
>
> USB? It's not 2.0. So no 54Mb/s for me. But this does present some
> confusion. 11Mb/s is still whatever.. ~1300 Kbytes/second, right? I just
> don't see how the 100K/s I'm getting can be confused with 1300K/s.
> They're not even close. Plus, what does this mean about the rates the
> Linksys status menu tells me I'm getting? 24-54 Mb/s. That range
> shouldn't even be possible, I'd thought.
>
> Okay, enough of that. I've used a Linksys product now and I have a very
> bad taste in my mouth. The snippets I've read from the closest thing I
> could find to reviews have been suggesting that Linksys is crap and
> D-Link is gold. Is this accurate? I'm going to probably be trading my
> current device in for something else. At this stage, I'm thinking D-Link
> is the way to go. Perhaps I'm wrong. I do reckon I'll go ahead and
> remove the soundcard so I can put a wireless card in its place. That way,
> even if I get bit by the Linksys bottleneck again, I can still look
> forward to (by the current math) about 500KB/s, which is adequate for my
> needs.
>
> Any help appreciated!



 
Reply With Quote
 
dusan
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      11-30-2003, 07:40 AM
hi
yes linksys must have some problem new out of the box bios and drivers
i just setup linksys on win xp home usb 54g and wrt54g bios 1.41.2 and i seen
only 1mb transfer speed no wap used just mac filtering
so next is to update wrt54g to latest bios and usb to latest bios and drivers
and see if that helps, or its posible that this linksys usb54g is junk/lemon

dusan

Marc Brown wrote:
> Subject says it all, really. I picked up one of these at Best Buy,
> installed it, and gave myself (and my brother) a four-hour headache trying
> to get WPA working with it (which was finally accomplished), only to note
> that the typical throughput is about 100-120 KBytes/second. Signal
> strength fluctuates between three and five bars, and it also seems to
> think I'm getting 24-54 Mb/s. I sure the heck am not. Stupid me for
> mapping a drive wirelessly; half the time, files sent to the wireless PC
> are completely lost because the bandwidth just wasn't good enough. This
> is totally unacceptable.
>
> Possibilities: WPA? It works, no doubt about that. I had to install a
> driver obtained from Microsoft's homepage. The router is definitely using
> WPA and the configuration menus for the Linksys WUSB54G definitely seem to
> be telling me that it's using WPA. Could this protection be causing the
> dramatically slow transfer rates? (If so, it's time to dump this adapter.)
>
> USB? It's not 2.0. So no 54Mb/s for me. But this does present some
> confusion. 11Mb/s is still whatever.. ~1300 Kbytes/second, right? I just
> don't see how the 100K/s I'm getting can be confused with 1300K/s.
> They're not even close. Plus, what does this mean about the rates the
> Linksys status menu tells me I'm getting? 24-54 Mb/s. That range
> shouldn't even be possible, I'd thought.
>
> Okay, enough of that. I've used a Linksys product now and I have a very
> bad taste in my mouth. The snippets I've read from the closest thing I
> could find to reviews have been suggesting that Linksys is crap and
> D-Link is gold. Is this accurate? I'm going to probably be trading my
> current device in for something else. At this stage, I'm thinking D-Link
> is the way to go. Perhaps I'm wrong. I do reckon I'll go ahead and
> remove the soundcard so I can put a wireless card in its place. That way,
> even if I get bit by the Linksys bottleneck again, I can still look
> forward to (by the current math) about 500KB/s, which is adequate for my
> needs.
>
> Any help appreciated!


 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
New to VPN, seeking advice Mike T. Home Networking 1 02-11-2007 06:24 PM
Seeking Advice on email Concerned Netizen Linux Networking 0 03-03-2005 08:17 PM
Seeking wireless LAN advice Ray Wireless Networks 8 08-11-2004 09:42 PM
seeking advice on changing from an 802.11b router to an 802.11g John Herleman Broadband Hardware 1 05-13-2004 06:00 PM
Seeking Advice Joe Liu Wireless Internet 1 10-14-2003 05:40 PM



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11