On 27 Nov 2005 02:02:19 -0800, "cherriesbaked"
<(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:
>Thanks for answering, I'm gona see if your answer works with my (poor)
>knowledge of computer network... By the way, "length of connection"
>means to me info about one shuting down its computer at night or during
>the day or not.
That's going to be a problem. Deciding whether a user has
intentionally disconnected or just driven out of wireless range is
difficult. Most routers will retain DHCP leases for many hours after
a wireless user has gone away. The ARP cache can be used to determine
if a user is still there, but that comes and goes rather quickly. If
your wireless network has multiple access points where users can roam
between them, the question of where a user is located is added to the
muddle. That's what 802.11r (fast roaming) is going to hopefully
solve. It is possible to determine if a user is still connected by
active means (i.e. ping their IP), but many client side personal
firewalls intentionally block ICMP and UDP ping packets. All this
causes problems when WISP (wireless ISP) operators want to provide
metered billing (by the minute). Some have resorted to proprietary
client software (Boingo) to do the job. Others require a VPN
connection (T-Mobile) which can be timed. I think you're on the right
track by measuring traffic instead of connect time.
>In fact, I'm looking for info that concerns only the activity of the
>network and meanwhile I hope this info can lead me to some suggestion
>like ; "is this computer downloading all night or all day long...?" I
>know for sure without being paranoid my ISP has this info and even
>further like in some explorer connect only sites that work with asp,
>java.
If all you want is aggregate (total) traffic, that's easy. Find a
router or switch that has SNMP capeabilities. You'll pay more but
it's worth it. I use MRTG and RRDTool to query the wireless router
for total traffic in both directions.
http://www.mrtg.org
http://people.ee.ethz.ch/~oetiker/webtools/rrdtool/
They produce nice historical graphs of total traffic. This is most
useful for detecting abuse and dealing with traffic failures such as
RF intereference because they display what is considered normal
traffic patterns. User counts can also be excavated via SNMP. Digging
deeper, most access point SNMP stacks will give traffic per MAC
address, which can be graphed. If it's a router, it will also have
the corresponding IP addresses.
You can also get traffic information by sniffing the traffic between
the access point and the router. This will also have all the users
MAC addresses. However, there is a gotacha. It will not show
wireless to wireless traffic, which does not go through the router
section and onward to the internet. If you have "client isolation"
enabled in the access points, no problem as there is no client to
client traffic. If you do have client to client traffic, sniffing
will not work.
>What I don't want to know is what sites the computers on my small
>network are visiting? It's not my job. I just want to warn a user of
>the network I "manage", that uses to much bandwith in a "suspect" way
>that if he keeps going on, he'll have no more connection.
Daily traffic quotas? It would be simple enough to use SNMP to
accumulate daily traffic statistics from perhaps midnight to midnight.
If any such traffic totals exceed an authorized value, then they get
an automatic nastygram in the email. Been there, done that, and it
doesn't work. The problem is that the alert appears much after the
abuse has taken place. Even setting quotas on a per hour basis proved
too late. It has to be caught quickly and dealt with immediately as
the support phones will start ringing immediately and the NOC will not
have a clue who or what is happening.
It's MUCH easier to not play policeman and simply install some form of
bandwidth management or QoS that proactively prevents abuse. Time
limiting is also possible such as Directway, which starts out fast,
but slows down after some level of traffic threshold has passed.
I don't have a specific suggestion that would not involve replacing
some of your hardware. I also have little clue as to what you have to
work with and how much of it supports SNMP. I suggest you look at the
various network monitoring tools available and decide what will work
for you.
Also, note that your users will probably need to authenticate with a
RADIUS server in order to simply identify which wireless connection
belongs to which users. It's very easy to change MAC addresses and
fool the NOC. That probably means a dedicated authentication server
and SNMP data collector. Whether this is worth the effort for 30
users is rather dubious.
You might find the following interesting.
http://martybugs.net/wireless/rrdtool/
http://martybugs.net/linux/rrdtool/traffic.cgi
--
Jeff Liebermann
(E-Mail Removed)
150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060
http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558
Similar Threads
Linear Mode
