Networking Forums

Networking Forums > Wireless Networking > Wireless Internet > What kind of distance would I get from this setup.

Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes

What kind of distance would I get from this setup.

 
 
inceebee
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      08-03-2008, 07:12 AM
I've got either a Linksys WRT54G or a Netgear WGR614 (http://
http://www.netgear.com/Products/Rout...rs/WGR614.aspx)
and I'm planning to mount an outdoor antenna like (http://
www.gnswireless.com/GNS1401.htm). Assuming that I hook it up with a
30' antenna cable and mount it at the top of the gable on a 2 story
house. What kind of distance do you think I can expect? For the sake
of argument, let's assume no trees in the way. In fact there is a
large tree in front of where I want to mount it, but I can work with
that.

Thanks for any input.
Nate Baxley
 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
 
DTC
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      08-03-2008, 01:03 PM
inceebee wrote:
> I've got either a Linksys WRT54G or a Netgear WGR614 (http://
> http://www.netgear.com/Products/Rout...rs/WGR614.aspx)
> and I'm planning to mount an outdoor antenna like (http://
> www.gnswireless.com/GNS1401.htm). Assuming that I hook it up with a
> 30' antenna cable and mount it at the top of the gable on a 2 story
> house. What kind of distance do you think I can expect? For the sake
> of argument, let's assume no trees in the way. In fact there is a
> large tree in front of where I want to mount it, but I can work with
> that.


There are too many unknowns to answer your question.

What kind of cable are you going to use? What is the attenuation?
How many connectors in the line? What kind of antenna or client radio
are you using at the other end?

What speed? Reliability? 6 Mbps with 90% reliability goes a lot
further than 54 Mbps and 99.99% uptime.

You'd be better off not using the Linksys. Its a mere 30 mW (15 dBm)
power output (forced setting by the Linksys internal firmware that you
CAN'T change unless you use the WRT54GL Linux based model and install
your own firmware). You can increase the power by a factor of ten for
300 mW (25 dBm), but it won't last very long.

Figure on using Time Microwave LMR-600 cable, about $90 or a 40 ft.
length with connectors installed, you'll have less than 3 dB loss.
Opps...forgot the lightning arrestor, there's another $40 and
an additional 2 dB loss.

You are way better off getting a REAL access point radio and a 12 dBi
antenna. You can mount it outdoors with a short low loss jumper.
You could probably get the AP and antenna and coax for under...
ummm, $360.

How far will it go? Several hundred feet to a laptop's internal card
IF you have line-of-sight.

Tell us what your are trying to accomplish and your expectations, and
then we can give you an assessment.


 
Reply With Quote
 
inceebee
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      08-04-2008, 09:02 PM
On Aug 3, 8:03*am, DTC <DTC@no_spam_nothing_here.foob> wrote:
> inceebee wrote:
> > I've got either a Linksys WRT54G or a Netgear WGR614 (http://
> >http://www.netgear.com/Products/Rout...rs/WGR614.aspx)
> > and I'm planning to mount an outdoor antenna like (http://
> >www.gnswireless.com/GNS1401.htm). *Assuming that I hook it up with a
> > 30' antenna cable and mount it at the top of the gable on a 2 story
> > house. *What kind of distance do you think I can expect? *For the sake
> > of argument, let's assume no trees in the way. *In fact there is a
> > large tree in front of where I want to mount it, but I can work with
> > that.

>
> There are too many unknowns to answer your question.
>
> What kind of cable are you going to use? What is the attenuation?
> How many connectors in the line? What kind of antenna or client radio
> are you using at the other end?
>
> What speed? Reliability? 6 Mbps with 90% reliability goes a lot
> further than 54 Mbps and 99.99% uptime.
>
> You'd be better off not using the Linksys. Its a mere 30 mW (15 dBm)
> power output (forced setting by the Linksys internal firmware that you
> CAN'T change unless you use the WRT54GL Linux based model and install
> your own firmware). You can increase the power by a factor of ten for
> 300 mW (25 dBm), but it won't last very long.
>
> Figure on using Time Microwave LMR-600 cable, about $90 or a 40 ft.
> length with connectors installed, you'll have less than 3 dB loss.
> Opps...forgot the lightning arrestor, there's another $40 and
> an additional 2 dB loss.
>
> You are way better off getting a REAL access point radio and a 12 dBi
> antenna. You can mount it outdoors with a short low loss jumper.
> You could probably get the AP and antenna and coax for under...
> ummm, $360.
>
> How far will it go? Several hundred feet to a laptop's internal card
> IF you have line-of-sight.
>
> Tell us what your are trying to accomplish and your expectations, and
> then we can give you an assessment.


Well, in case it doesn't show, I'm new to anything beyond dropping in
an AP and going. :-) What I'm trying to do is extend my WiFi out to
my back patio and an out building that is about 100ft away. I have a
WiFi access point in a 2nd floor closet, in the middle of the house.
I just replaced the Netgear I mentioned above with a Belkin (http://
http://www.amazon.com/Belkin-Wireles...dp/B00008ZPJU),
but neither will give me much of a signal outside the house. The
house is an old farmhouse and has built on to many times, and has
several think walls plus an asbestos siding that I think has a wire
mesh backing. So, I'm pretty sure I'll need something on the outside
of the house. The patio is just below the gable end of my house and
the second building is, as I said 100ft from the gable end in the same
direction. I had been planning to mount an antenna on the gable end
and put the actual access point inside the closet with the other AP
and run the antenna cord as I mentioned. I suppose a standalone
device would work, but I'm trying to keep my costs down if possible.
Under $200 for sure. I currently don't have any POE equipment, so if
I need to power the standalone AP over ethernet, I'll need to include
an injector.

As for the tree, I am actually planning on taking it out as it is
starting to die and is very close to the house. It actually comes
about 3 ft. from the gable end I mentioned. I will be replacing it
with another new tree that will be off set and not as close to the
house. Plus of course I'll have quite a few years until it's as big
as the current 30 year old tree. That patio will just be used by
laptops, but the machines in the other building will be desktops, and
I'll probably get a bridge to retrieve the signal. The outbuilding
has a more standard 4" wall with drywall on the inside and wooden
siding on the outside, so penetrating it shouldn't be as hard.

Of course, if the other building becomes too much trouble I may just
bury a conduit and run cable direct to it.

Hopefully that is enough extra information and the right kind. I
appreciate your patience with a WiFi newbie.
 
Reply With Quote
 
DTC
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      08-04-2008, 09:25 PM
Mount the Linksys or whatever you use close to where you are going to
point the antenna, even if it means putting it in the nearest bedroom.
That way your coax cost and loss will be minimal. If you CAN'T get the
unit close to a AC Power outlet, even with an extension cord, you can
do a poor man's PoE.

http://www.streakwave.com/Itemdesc.a...17-105&eq=&Tp=
 
Reply With Quote
 
AnthonyL
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      08-05-2008, 11:41 AM
On Sun, 3 Aug 2008 00:12:01 -0700 (PDT), inceebee
<(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:

>Assuming that I hook it up with a
>30' antenna cable and mount it at the top of the gable on a 2 story
>house.


Do look up losses on cable - they can be quite substantial and
anything over a couple of metres is very noticeable.


--
AnthonyL
 
Reply With Quote
 
DTC
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      08-05-2008, 07:00 PM
LR wrote:
> inceebee wrote:
>> . The patio is just below the gable end of my house

>
> Note that the vertical beamwidth of the Antenna you were looking at is
> only 15 degrees so might get poor to no coverage on the patio.
> If your other building is only 100ft away you may find the laptops are
> below the 3dB beamwidth.


Even a 9 dBi antenna at 40 feet high will work to a laptop at the
base of the mast. The -3 DB beamwidth is where the signal drops
3 dB, but there is still a lot of signal under the antenna.
 
Reply With Quote
 
jimmie68@gmail.com
Guest
Posts: n/a

 
      08-06-2008, 10:41 PM
On Aug 4, 5:02*pm, inceebee <Nate.Bax...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Aug 3, 8:03*am, DTC <DTC@no_spam_nothing_here.foob> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> > inceebee wrote:
> > > I've got either a Linksys WRT54G or a Netgear WGR614 (http://
> > >http://www.netgear.com/Products/Rout...rs/WGR614.aspx)
> > > and I'm planning to mount an outdoor antenna like (http://
> > >www.gnswireless.com/GNS1401.htm). *Assuming that I hook it up with a
> > > 30' antenna cable and mount it at the top of the gable on a 2 story
> > > house. *What kind of distance do you think I can expect? *For thesake
> > > of argument, let's assume no trees in the way. *In fact there is a
> > > large tree in front of where I want to mount it, but I can work with
> > > that.

>
> > There are too many unknowns to answer your question.

>
> > What kind of cable are you going to use? What is the attenuation?
> > How many connectors in the line? What kind of antenna or client radio
> > are you using at the other end?

>
> > What speed? Reliability? 6 Mbps with 90% reliability goes a lot
> > further than 54 Mbps and 99.99% uptime.

>
> > You'd be better off not using the Linksys. Its a mere 30 mW (15 dBm)
> > power output (forced setting by the Linksys internal firmware that you
> > CAN'T change unless you use the WRT54GL Linux based model and install
> > your own firmware). You can increase the power by a factor of ten for
> > 300 mW (25 dBm), but it won't last very long.

>
> > Figure on using Time Microwave LMR-600 cable, about $90 or a 40 ft.
> > length with connectors installed, you'll have less than 3 dB loss.
> > Opps...forgot the lightning arrestor, there's another $40 and
> > an additional 2 dB loss.

>
> > You are way better off getting a REAL access point radio and a 12 dBi
> > antenna. You can mount it outdoors with a short low loss jumper.
> > You could probably get the AP and antenna and coax for under...
> > ummm, $360.

>
> > How far will it go? Several hundred feet to a laptop's internal card
> > IF you have line-of-sight.

>
> > Tell us what your are trying to accomplish and your expectations, and
> > then we can give you an assessment.

>
> Well, in case it doesn't show, I'm new to anything beyond dropping in
> an AP and going. *:-) *What I'm trying to do is extend my WiFi out to
> my back patio and an out building that is about 100ft away. *I have a
> WiFi access point in a 2nd floor closet, in the middle of the house.
> I just replaced the Netgear I mentioned above with a Belkin (http://www.amazon.com/Belkin-Wireles...dp/B00008ZPJU),
> but neither will give me much of a signal outside the house. *The
> house is an old farmhouse and has built on to many times, and has
> several think walls plus an asbestos siding that I think has a wire
> mesh backing. *So, I'm pretty sure I'll need something on the outside
> of the house. *The patio is just below the gable end of my house and
> the second building is, as I said 100ft from the gable end in the same
> direction. *I had been planning to mount an antenna on the gable end
> and put the actual access point inside the closet with the other AP
> and run the antenna cord as I mentioned. *I suppose a standalone
> device would work, but I'm trying to keep my costs down if possible.
> Under $200 for sure. *I currently don't have any POE equipment, so if
> I need to power the standalone AP over ethernet, I'll need to include
> an injector.
>
> As for the tree, I am actually planning on taking it out as it is
> starting to die and is very close to the house. *It actually comes
> about 3 ft. from the gable end I mentioned. *I will be replacing it
> with another new tree that will be off set and not as close to the
> house. *Plus of course I'll have quite a few years until it's as big
> as the current 30 year old tree. *That patio will just be used by
> laptops, but the machines in the other building will be desktops, and
> I'll probably get a bridge to retrieve the signal. *The outbuilding
> has a more standard 4" wall with drywall on the inside and wooden
> siding on the outside, so penetrating it shouldn't be as hard.
>
> Of course, if the other building becomes too much trouble I may just
> bury a conduit and run cable direct to it.
>
> Hopefully that is enough extra information and the right kind. *I
> appreciate your patience with a WiFi newbie.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -


I had a similar bill to fill. I had coverage on my back patio but not
across the yard in my gazebo(wife wanted to use her laptop there).
Anyway I had a spare wrt54gs to play with so I set it up for repeater
use using DD- WRT software. We move it around to a few places to fill
holes in our coverage.

Jimmie
 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
what kind of equipment I need for long distance WIFI kustomjs Wireless Internet 7 12-10-2007 10:40 PM
Looking for missing piece in WLAN long distance setup bigeeguy Wireless Internet 1 08-21-2007 07:11 AM
Long distance wireless network setup question Flatshovel Wireless Internet 1 07-21-2007 11:36 PM
what kind of? Vinnie Wireless Internet 3 08-10-2006 08:20 PM
Help requested with a different kind of setup Isaac Grover Wireless Internet 1 07-25-2006 05:58 AM



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11