Eeyore wrote in message
(E-Mail Removed):
> Why do you need a modem ? They're often thrown in to entice you to
> join the poorer ISPs. The really good ones almost never offer
> freebies. You're better off with an ADSL router modem ( ethernet )
> anyway and they don't cost much.
I had a bad experience which makes my recommend that customers take the
modem that their ISP is offering, even if they are planning to buy a router.
One of my customers with Wanadoo opted for no modem because I was buying him
a router. Having installed the router, there was no detectable ADSL carrier.
Same with my own router. Swapped socket-to-wall cable and microfilter. But
because it was a third-party router rather than their own modem, they did
not take the problem seriously and send a BT Broadband engineer to test the
signal as received at the master socket - I must have told the Indian
call-centre staff till I was blue in the face that the problem happened with
more than one router, but they still said "It's not one of our modems, so
the problem must lie with the router".
So I'd say "get a modem as a diagnostic device". That way, if there's a
problem, you can say truthfully that you've tried with the modem that they
supplied - maybe then the ISP will take the fault report seriously.