"Don W." <dNOSPAMwiddersAThotmail.com> wrote in message
news:NOOcnY5HL4d7IOCiXTWc-(E-Mail Removed)...
> "Jack" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message
> news:(E-Mail Removed) om...
> > Saying that its impossible to have a sector antenna of 15db is not
> > true. You can follow the following URL to see
> > (http://www.hyperlinktech.com/web/ant...out_sector.php) from
> > 15 to 20dbi antennas of 90 to 180 degrees.
> >
> > Now anyone can say how to build sector antenna of 90 degrees beam and
> > 15 or 17dbi power.
>
> I didn't say a 15 dBi sector antenna is impossible. I wrote "The antenna
> you're describing is not possible." The antenna you described was:
> "Above 15dbm ; min 80 degree horizontal coverage ; min 70 degree virtical
> coverage"
>
> Read on in the hyperlinktech page and tell me if you find any antenna with
> such broad coverage with "Above 15dbm". FYI, the HG2415P-180 has only a
10
> degree vertical angle. You specified 70 degrees, that's 7 times the
> coverage area which knocks almost 4 dBi off the antenna gain.
>
> Note that I also wrote:
> "The wider the angle of coverage, the lower the gain figure. Most sector
> antennas have a very narrow vertical beamwidth. That's how they achieve
> higher gain and that's also the reason you see them in clusters on cell
> sites, pointed slightly down."
>
> The antenna you initially described is not possible.
>
> Don W.
>
It appears I made two errors that almost cancel each other. In the end your
description is still an impossible antenna.
First, I wrote that the HG2415P-180 has only a 10 degree vertical angle.
The vertical beamwidth is actually + or - 10 degrees, so it has a 20 degree
beamwidth. I went on to say that one seventh the gain is minus 4 dB. One
seventh the gain is really close to minus 6 dB, but I should have said that
70 degrees represents a 71.4% increase in coverage area over the HG2415P-180
and a reduction in gain of .286 times or a gain decrease of almost 5.5 dB.
You also specified 80 degrees horizontal coverage and the HG2415P-180 has
180 degree coverage, so this will increase the gain of your antenna by a
factor of 2.25 or 3.5 dB, so your antenna ends up at about 15 - 5.5 + 3.5 =
13 dBi which is about a 58% decrease in gain from the HG2415P-180. So using
the same efficiency factor as the HG2415P-180, your specs render a 13 dBi
antenna. I'm not saying the efficiency of the HG2415P-180 cannot be
improved upon, but I don't believe an additional 2 dBi (58%) improvement in
efficiency is possible.
Don W.